Aug. 15, 2013
KEY WORDS: constructive communication, moral education, structure of an educational activity, students’ subjectivity, ‘structure of a communicative activity’, experimental work with high school teachers.
ABSTRACT: The author, a famous Russian academic, presents the results of a short research which allowed him and his team not only to better understand the nature and process of creating constructive communication but also to help high school students view this communication as a value among other important individual values.
As both research and pedagogical practice show, one of the results of moral education is a developed interest of high school students in the ways of constructive communication and their striving for acclaiming these ways. In this process, constructive communication among students may be considered an important value.
By the term constructive communication we understand such communication that allows to reach out for somebody and also to receive this person’s agreement with different partners and, particularly, to find ways out of different conflicts, which will satisfy all the parties involved.
Our research (Pyotr G. Averianov, Elena L. Petrenko, Sergey D. Polyakov, Inna J. Shustova) tends to answer the question, how a teacher can stimulate this interest and develop necessary skills (Averianov et.al., 2010). We base our experimental work on the stages of psychical development presented in the works of a famous Russian psychologist Daniel Elkonin, and the theory of the developing educational activity by Vasily Davydov.
According to Davydov, the development of any educational activity has the following structure and consists of:
Students’ ndividual educational activity first emerges and develops in their joint activities with a teacher – namely, in their joint analysis of a problem situation, in their shared creation of a graphic model of this phenomenon to study, and finally, in their combined elaboration of the rules. By the rules here we mean certain patterns of how to apply and analyze achieved results.
This idea was postulated by Lev Vygotsky (Vygotsky, 1999), an outstanding psychologist of the 20th century, and based on his understanding of transforming inter-psychic developments into intra-psychic.
We asked ourselves a question, what if it is possible to apply the same Elconin-Davydov’s “structure of an educational activity” to moral education?
Elconin considered that the leading activity for teenagers, in other words, the activity which is most sensitive for their psychic development, was communication with their peers (Elconin, 1971).
From the point of view of the “activity theory”, moral education should lead to elaboration of such joint communicative activity by the teacher when students develop an interest in discovering and applying the laws of constructive communication.
In order to elaborate this process and help it happen, a teacher:
The result of such moral education is a personality of a student as a subject of his/her communicative activity. However, a student’s subjective standpoint can manifest itself in different ways.
As a result of our research, we have singled out four levels of developing students’ subjectivity in their communicative activities:
Level 0. A student is unaware of being instructed in communication in the process of the joint activity with teachers.
Level 1. A student concentrates on situations when his/her peers were instructed in communication in the process of the joint activity with the teacher, but considers his/her own activity low.
Level 2. A student concentrates on situations of instructing peers in communication in the process of the joint activity, and considers his/her own activity high.
Level 3. A student considers applying communication laws in the process of the joint activity important for being discussed and used.
Originally, in our experimental research there were involved who eleven teachers carried out a program of a group activity aimed at creating special motivation of the communicative activity and acclaiming special actions.
The teachers who were the research participants went through a special training which allowed them to master theory and techniques of communicative activities.
The experimental research of that first phase was aimed at testing the hypothesis of developing high school students’ communicative activity as their ability to maintain effective communication with peers under certain conditions.
In order to analyze the results, we have elaborated a set of diagnostic methods that allow to discover the degree of students’ striving for acclaiming the ways of constructive communication.
Positive progress in students’ striving for acclaiming constructive communication was registered in 10 out of 11 experimental class groups. The result of this first stage is that the number of students, who consider both their participating in the joint activity and applying the laws of communication important, has increased.
Therefore, we can consider that moral education in terms of developing a communicative activity is possible by analogy with developing educational activity according to Elconin-Davydov.
But there are some other questions to answer and issues to resolve:
The next stage of our experiment included the analysis of the process of creating students’ orientation towards a constructive communication as a value while being involved in the organized group activity.
There were six teachers participating in this part of the experiment.
The diagnostic component of the experiment was extended. This time high school students carried out a set of diagnostic tests which revealed their interest in four groups of values connected with the content and the topic of the activity, ways of organizing this activity, typical values of the peers and, finally, personal values of the teachers.
The diagnostics of the level of the students’ subjectivity in the process of communicative activity and the character of their value systems was performed at the beginning and at the end of the organized activity.
The results of this part of the experimental work revealed the following:
The system of ranks before the joint activity appeared as follows:
The system of ranks after the joint activity went as following:
Thus, the results of this second part of the experimental work proved the possibility of stimulating high school students’ striving for acclaiming constructive communication as a value under certain conditions of an experimental group activity.
References
Home | Copyright © 2024, Russian-American Education Forum